I would rule out an assistant that cannot read the inbox the job depends on. Poke documents Gmail and Outlook support, while Instinct describes Google Workspace connections. That makes account access the first check for a recurring inbox brief.
I compared each company’s own documentation on 3 October 2026. I haven’t run the same task on both.
Poke vs Instinct at a glance
Table legend: A dash means the linked source leaves that detail open. Questions name a gap to resolve before relying on that row.
| Decision criterion | Poke | Instinct |
|---|---|---|
| Eligibility and availability | Docs claim worldwide availability; terms require age 13+ and contract eligibility or guardian permission. | Terms require age 18+; Ask: can I sign up in my country?. |
| Where you reach it | Apple Messages, WhatsApp, Telegram and RCS. | Text and calls. |
| Recurring and background work | Recipes and reminders; Pro adds background automations. | Proactive follow-ups and bookings; Ask: can I set a daily schedule? |
| Approval boundaries | Ask: does every send wait for my OK?. | Terms authorize actions; confirmation safeguards are discretionary. |
| Memory and export | Memory described; Ask: can I export memory?. | Connected context; memory controls: —. |
| Receipts and failures | Integration error indicators documented; Ask: does the record include every action and failure? | Terms discuss action records and warn of inaccuracies; receipt coverage: —. |
| Published monthly price | Free $0; Pro $19; Ultra $199 plus usage beyond credits. | Ask: what will my plan cost? |
Can you use it with your account?
Poke’s FAQ supports Gmail and Outlook inboxes, calendars and contacts, but excludes iCloud and Yahoo Mail. Start with your inbox. An unsupported one rules out that recurring job.
Instinct’s privacy policy describes Google Workspace connections including Gmail, Calendar and Drive, while its homepage names optional messaging, screen, audio and location context for the assistant to read when you allow it. These are sources it can read with your permission.
Poke’s terms and Instinct’s terms grant personal-use access. A founder assigning company work should clarify permitted use before connecting a company inbox.
I would favor Poke for a messaging buyer who needs a documented Gmail or Outlook connection. I would favor Instinct for an adult considering phone-based personal assistance, once their country and account access are confirmed.
Will a morning research task run in the background?
I would start with Poke for a timed connected-app brief. Its integration guide describes Recipes setting up connections and a starting behavior such as a daily issue summary, while the usage guide says Pro adds background automations and demanding work waits for a reset when the allowance runs out. Check the next run.
Instinct describes dropped-thread follow-ups and proactive calls or texts. Before assigning a timed brief, ask Instinct about user-set schedules, limits and failed-run notifications. Its checked material leaves those open.
I would shortlist Poke for morning research, after checking the schedule, time zone, sources and allowance. Instinct’s calls fit unfinished personal errands more closely.
Example brief. Sam wants a weekday report at 7:00: “Check these five pages for changes, link each changed passage, and list anything you could not read. Do not contact anyone or publish anything.” The desired result is a short report with five source statuses, including an explicit failure for an unavailable page.
Inspect the next scheduled execution and ask how a failed connection or exhausted allowance appears. A blank report should never be mistaken for five unchanged pages.
What stops an inbox follow-up before it sends?
For client follow-ups, my choice is an agent with a send gate I can inspect. Poke’s FAQ describes Ultra’s separate human-assistance option, where a person receives task details without access to your history, memory or integrations, so those controls tell you what human help can see while leaving the AI’s send-approval rule to check separately.
Instinct’s terms authorize connected-service actions and say confirmation controls may be introduced. I would ask to see the exact send boundary in the account, including what happens when a recurring task has an earlier permission grant.
Keep Poke and Instinct on draft-only work until you have confirmed a send gate in the account. The approval policy builder names the readable mailbox, allowed recipients and action that waits. An instruction to ask first needs an enforced stop behind it.
For example, Sam’s brief could be: “List replies I owe and draft three nudges. Hold each send until I approve its recipient and exact text.” The review needs to show the unsent draft, the decision and the resulting mailbox state. Check the mailbox too.
Can you correct memory and move results out?
Poke describes using memory with integrated services. Instinct’s privacy policy describes collecting context from permitted connections. Neither source describes a memory editor or portable export. I would keep the master copy of recipient rules outside either assistant; choose OperatorNest if those preferences need to move with the agent.
Ask separately about the report, conversation and remembered preferences. A copied morning report may cover today’s handoff while leaving behind the recipient rules that shaped it. Request a sample of each export you need and check whether it contains source links, timestamps and corrections you made.
Save what you need before deletion. Poke’s FAQ gives account deletion up to 24 hours with backup and legal-retention exceptions, while Instinct’s privacy policy says disconnecting an integration leaves collected data and indexed copies need a separate removal request.
What record can you inspect after the work?
Poke’s integration guide documents connection error indicators and retry or refresh controls. Those diagnose disconnected sources. They don’t describe a full action-and-failure receipt. Instinct’s terms refer to action records but warn that they may be inaccurate.
Request a sample approval trail with the instruction, sources, draft, decision, external action and failures, then check who can read it and how long it stays available. A transcript can explain what was said without showing everything that happened.
What does the published price cover?
Poke’s monthly pricing, checked October 3, 2026, lists Free at $0, Pro at $19 with background automations and Ultra at $199 plus usage beyond credits; the usage guide describes falling back to Pro, buying top-ups or enabling automatic reloads when credits run out. Include usage in the budget.
I would start a budget-conscious recurring-task buyer with the Pro allowance and the frequency of their job. Price the number of runs you need, including the allowance reset that can delay a time-sensitive report.
Instinct’s terms describe paid services but give no amount. A price comparison needs its offer. Request the applicable offer, usage limits and any additional charges before comparing total cost.
If you need portable memory and model choice
If you need 24/7 recurring work with a model you choose, memory you can inspect and export, and approvals with receipts, OperatorNest offers those controls. The personal AI agent buyer guide covers the wider shortlist. Poke’s documented messaging automations or Instinct’s text-and-call assistance may fit your job without those requirements.